Trigger warning, as defined by dictionary.com, is a stated warning that the content of a text, video, etc., may upset or offend some people, especially those who have previously experienced a related trauma. College students are increasingly anxious, and widespread adoption of trigger warnings in syllabi may promote this trend, tacitly encouraging students to turn to avoidance, thereby depriving them of opportunities to learn healthier ways to manage potential distress.” About three-fourths of us will experience trauma over the course of our lifetime. All participants were then exposed to the content and subsequently asked to report on the extent to which they experienced distress, negative emotions or intrusive thoughts related to it. © 2021 Forbes Media LLC. The trend echoes a wave of trigger warnings in universities acorss America, after some colleges highlighted material containing references to subjects such … Viewers like you help make PBS (Thank you ) . One is to include them at the beginning of a course. Safe Spaces On College Campuses Are Creating Intolerant Students. Another objection to trigger warnings is that they are a poor substitute for the professional treatment and support needed by student victims of sexual assault and other mental or physical trauma and that they risk shifting attention and resources away from the problem of sexual violence on college and university campuses by focusing on reading lists and class discussions. Trigger warnings, or brief statements that warn about potentially upsetting content, are on the rise on college campuses, with 51% of professors reporting that they now use them. Some subjects were given a message prior to the material they were soon to see. Intended to shield students from what they might experience as distressing or traumatizing, trigger warnings remain controversial. With a seeming increase in political correctness across college campuses in recent years, trigger warnings and safe spaces seemed an inevitable path. Instead of creating an environment for thought provoking input, schools … This school year, the University of Chicago has put the debate over "trigger warnings" on campus back in the news. Opinion: Trigger warning: An embarrassing fragility on college campuses. Soon the term and the practice were applied to other discussions in the interest of protecting the sufferers and victims of a wide range of disorders, conditions, and traumas, including eating disorders, self-mutilation, suicidal tendencies, and domestic abuse. In an official document issued in 2013 (later withdrawn), Oberlin College advised its faculty to “be aware of racism, classism, sexism, heterosexism, cissexism [transphobia], ableism, and other issues of privilege and oppression”; to “remove triggering material when it does not contribute directly to the course learning goals”; and to issue warnings of the existence of triggering material in texts that are “too important to avoid.” For example, although Chinua Achebe’s novel Things Fall Apart “is a triumph of literature that everyone in the world should read,” it “may trigger readers who have experienced racism, colonialism, religious persecution, violence, suicide, and more.” The document further recommended that instructors “strongly consider developing a policy to make triggering material optional.”. The same can happen with readings about racism or … In a study published in 2018, McNally and his colleagues found that subjects receiving trigger warnings prior to reading literary passages that varied in disturbing content reported greater anxiety to material perceived as harmful than did subjects receiving no warnings. Trigger warnings are not the answer. Neither did a personal history of trauma; participants who reported they had experienced actual trauma in their lives responded to the distressing material similarly, regardless of whether it was preceded by a trigger warning or not. However, trigger warnings are also a method of sheltering students and should be abandoned by school systems immediately. The researchers conducted six experiments involving 1,394 subjects, some of which were college students and others who were online participants. Including content or trigger warnings is an issue of accessibility, as having panic attacks in class (a common outcome when a trigger is unexpectedly encountered) can prevent a student from learning and adversely impacts their health and wellbeing. Opinion: Trigger warning: An embarrassing fragility on college campuses. About half of all college professors told National Public Radio in a 2016 survey that they'd used trigger warnings to prepare students for potentially difficult material. Others feel that such warnings … Trigger warnings will not solve this problem, but only misdirect attention from it and, in the process, threaten the academic freedom of teachers and students whose classrooms should be open to difficult discussions, whatever form they take. (Ben Margot/AP) ... Lyell Asher, professor of English at Lewis & Clark College… Institutional mandates that faculty use trigger warnings interfere with academic freedom in the choice of course materials and teaching methods, the report says. Brian Duignan is a senior editor at Encyclopædia Britannica. Indeed, many of the newly proposed triggers differ in a variety of important ways from the classic triggers associated with sexual and physical trauma. Ideological safe spaces make those on the left and the right more extreme. Campus trigger warnings are statements cautioning individuals that they are about to be exposed to content in readings, classes, films or speeches they may find upsetting. By Samantha Rodman, PhD. Students can use warnings not to prepare … In the words of Mevagh Sanson, senior author of the study, “The results suggest a trigger warning is neither meaningfully helpful nor harmful.”. By the early 2010s the trigger-warning movement had appeared on college and university campuses and had expanded in scope to encompass victims of injustice, discrimination, and oppression, who could be painfully reminded of their experiences by course material that dealt too explicitly with injustice, discrimination, and oppression. In the 1960s college students demanded the right to talk about anything on campus, from civil rights to opposing the Vietnam War. This study did not include previously traumatized individuals or those with clinical disorders. Colleges concerned about their students' mental health should follow McNally's advice: focus on improving access to on-campus mental health services. Across all the variations in the studies, trigger warnings had trivial effects. Such avoidance reinforces anxiety, rather than reducing it, inadvertently leading individuals to believe that their prior trauma remains laden with danger. Much like safe spaces, trigger warnings provide an essential function to students who struggle with past trauma or mental illness, particularly PTSD or panic disorders. Support your local PBS Member Station here: https://to.pbs.org/donateidea Trigger Warnings In College! The Atlantic: The Coddling of the American Mind; Einzelnachweise This can be said verbally, shown in text, and in online media shown through hashtags. Trigger warnings, the heads-up that college professors give to students to let them know disturbing content is coming, have gotten a lot of attention as the school year has unfolded. Impact 50: Investors Seeking Profit — And Pushing For Change, Four Priorities To Watch From President Biden’s $750 Billion College Proposal, Coursera Launches Higher Ed Initiatives Aimed At Black Learners, How Systems And States Can Encourage More And Better Project-Based Learning, U.K. However, talking openly about why trigger warnings are helpful to others, or could be, can open their eyes to how different someone else’s experiences can be. At for-profit colleges, strict curriculum control and enrollment contracts effectively restrict all critical literature and pedagogy. Following retirement from Missouri State in 2011, I became senior policy advisor to Missouri Governor Jay Nixon. private colleges. It is not enough to protect students from physical violence. On other campuses, trigger warnings have been proposed for specific works, including (in addition to Metamorphoses) F. Scott Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby (suicide and domestic violence), Virginia Woolf’s Mrs. Dalloway (suicide), and Shakespeare’s The Merchant of Venice (anti-Semitism). Some in higher education argue that providing students with trigger warnings means taking students seriously. All Rights Reserved, This is a BETA experience. Some professors offer what they call trigger warnings at the beginning of a course only and others for imminent content. A “trigger warning,” on the other hand, refers specifically to psychological triggers that might cause an extreme and unconscious reaction for people who have experienced trauma, like physical or sexual assault, combat, or natural disasters. Why I Am A Convert To The Idea Of "Trigger Warnings" Originally, I felt that since the exposure therapy is known to facilitate the recovery from trauma, trigger warnings could. According to a 2015 survey by the National Coalition Against Censorship (NCAC), only a tiny minority of colleges and universities (1 percent) now require trigger warnings. Monica Almeida/The New York Times Here’s why I … The most common method for offering trigger warnings was to give verbal warnings throughout the semester. The implications for academic freedom, freedom of speech, the value of a university education, and the future of the university itself are of concern to school officials. Recently, I have authored two books: Degrees and Pedigrees: The Education of America's Top Executives (2017) and Coming to Grips With Higher Education (2018), both published by Rowman & Littlefield. “Triggered” and “offended/upset” are not the same concept. “Trigger*” is used to talk about PTSD and mental illness. Whether trigger warnings do more harm than good or simply do little at all, their use in the interests of protecting or promoting students' psychological well-being appears misplaced. Trigger Warnings Colleges typically define trigger warning as an alert—issued by a professor—about something within a book, video, presentation, discussion, or other type of course material that may cause a student to experience intense emotional distress. Where did they come from? I am president emeritus of Missouri State University. Safe Spaces: Before going any deeper after the necessity of the safe spaces, we must know what the safe spaces mean. The University told incoming freshmen that, … The movement generally called for (voluntary or mandatory) trigger warnings in course syllabi for material that might provoke a strong negative emotional reaction in some students or for the outright removal of such material from the curriculum. Trigger warnings became particularly prevalent in self-help and feminist forums, where they allowed readers who had suffered from traumatic events … Put simply, a trigger warning is a heads up, or warning, that the content about to be discussed may trigger difficult emotional reactions, or bring up difficult memories. JVS: There are a lot of different theories around trigger warnings. Students often request or even demand such warnings as a protection from potentially disturbing content, while many faculty and university officials are disdainful, viewing them as examples of excessive political correctness, threats to free speech, or the unnecessary coddling of overly sensitive students. After earning my B.A. Thinking about things from another person’s experience like that definitely encourages critical thinking and … Trigger warnings are messages alerting people to content containing themes that could cause distressing emotional reactions. Trigger warnings are meant to give people with post-traumatic stress disorder, and others who have experienced trauma, an idea of the content they're about to … What is a trigger warning? That practice is probably the most controversial of all, since critics say it comes at the cost of personal growth and … A trigger warning doesn’t necessarily stop me from engaging with content, but it does help me prepare for what I might endure. A normative exclusion as opposed to a regulatory one? Universities Face Financial Loss As Brexit Hits E.U. For some students, trigger warnings may feel silly or unnecessary, and they might not even understand why someone would need such a thing. The basic rationale for trigger warnings is that the college classroom should be a safe space. A few months later, the college tabled the trigger warning policy to be reworked; it hasn't yet been rewritten. Trigger warnings and safe spaces have become a much-discussed topic of college student culture as covered in the media. I am president emeritus of Missouri State University. Opinions expressed by Forbes Contributors are their own. Trigger Warnings and College Courses The conversation about trigger warnings inevitably references academic freedom, the right to feel safe on campus, freedom of speech, and the proposition that the college classroom should be a “laboratory” in which students and faculty may explore, analyze, and critique even the most controversial and offensive ideas and human behavior. The University of California, Santa Barbara, where student leaders passed a resolution in favor of trigger warnings. A "content warning" is basically the same thing. By signing up for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, and information from Encyclopaedia Britannica. By Flemming Rose. Not only are many topics within psychology courses potential triggers, but psychology is at the forefront of clinical science and evidencebased pedagogy. The results? Another is to use the topic at hand to say some students might be affected by this subject matter. A research team, led by a postdoctoral fellow at the University of Waikato, (New Zealand) has just published a large-scale study that examines whether trigger warnings act as intended – reducing distress for people later exposed to upsetting information – or misfire – priming anxiety in individuals who are led by the warnings to expect and experience negative affect. from Wheaton College (Illinois), I was awarded a Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the University of Illinois in 1973. Even on those campuses, however, the debate regarding trigger warnings was unresolved, and the national controversy showed no signs of abating anytime soon. The term, often used interchangeably with “content warning,” is a heads up that readers may encounter distressing content—and in recent years, trigger or content warnings have become controversial. The trigger-warning debate presents faculty members and administrators with a difficult decision: Should they prioritize defending free speech or helping students feel emotionally safe? We elites balk at such barbarism. The debate about trigger warnings on college campuses is largely similar to the one about safe spaces. Ring in the new year with a Britannica Membership. “College students are increasingly anxious … and widespread adoption of trigger warnings in syllabi may promote this trend, tacitly encouraging students to turn to … Recently, some colleges and universities have bucked this trend. Trigger warnings are not about oversensitivity – they are about empathy, and recognizing the varied experiences of all students at this university.” 1 Many mental health experts note, however, that trigger warnings are not the end-all-be-all in the college environment. Waves of media attention tell us that college students are demanding that professors provide so-called ‘trigger warnings’ to flag material that might cause distress or discomfort, or possibly trigger a panic attack in students with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). College professors are staring to second think on what course material to teach, because many students become offended with what comes out of the professor’s mouth, this … What is a trigger warning? Is their aim true? In a 2015 letter to their student newspaper, four undergraduates at Columbia University called on the administration to officially encourage instructors to issue warnings to potential students of any “triggering and offensive material” in their courses. Are they helpful or harmful? Viewers like you help make PBS (Thank you ) . The University of California at Berkeley. Critics of trigger warnings have asserted that they are infantilizing, treating students like children who cannot be exposed to a disagreeable idea (or even to criticism of a disagreeable idea) without becoming upset; that they are crudely anti-intellectual and even antieducational, since in their broadest application they invite students to dismiss virtually all of world history, literature, and culture; that they poorly prepare students for constructively dealing with conflict and disagreement in the real world; that they threaten the academic freedom of instructors to teach courses in their areas of expertise as they see fit; and that they undermine freedom of speech and freedom of inquiry by preemptively closing off discussion of potentially offensive ideas. Trigger is the key word here. In recent discussions of trigger warnings-“alerts that professors are expected to issue if something in a course might cause a strong emotional response”, is a controversial issue that has been whether trigger warnings at colleges/universities should be issued to students who wish to be alerted on unappealing subjects or to not have triggered warnings from being practiced in American Universities. By the early 2010s the trigger-warning movement had appeared on college and university campuses and had expanded in scope to encompass victims of injustice, discrimination, and oppression, who could be painfully reminded of their experiences by course material that dealt too explicitly with injustice, discrimination, and oppression. George F. Will. The announced policy—which notably did not prohibit individual professors from issuing trigger warnings or organizing safe spaces—reflected the conclusions of the university’s faculty-constituted Committee on Freedom of Expression, which stated in its 2015 report that “concerns about civility and mutual respect can never be used as a justification for closing off discussion of ideas, however offensive or disagreeable those ideas may be to some members of our community.” Clearly influenced by the report, several other universities, including Princeton and Columbia, soon adopted policies similar to that of Chicago. Universities Spending $1 Billion Or More On R And D, They Call Themselves #GenGeo—And They Aren't Waiting To Inherit The Earth, many faculty and university officials are disdainful. Yet to be known for certain is whether trigger warnings might be beneficial for students who suffer from diagnosable psychological disorders such as depression or posttraumatic stress disorder. The term trigger warning originated in the late 1990s on feminist Internet message boards, where it referred to site-sponsored cautions to readers regarding the presence of graphic depictions of rape in certain posts. The letter writers referred to the case of a female student in a general literature class, a victim of sexual assault, who had experienced extreme distress and felt unsafe after having read depictions of rape in Ovid’s Metamorphoses, an assigned text. An example: “TRIGGER WARNING: The following video may contain graphic footage of a fatal car crash. Although trigger warnings are hotly debated in higher education, serving like a Rorschach card upon which one’s political views of college life are projected, little is actually known about their impact. Proponents of the warnings argue that they could serve a preventive purpose for such individuals, but experts on anxiety disorders, like Harvard’s Richard McNally, suggest just the opposite effect – an increase in emotional vulnerability to trauma following warnings. In June 2016, the University of Chicago stated in a letter to all incoming freshmen that it does not support trigger warnings and does not condone “safe spaces,” or places on campus in which like-minded students may gather to avoid exposure to words or ideas that upset them. Trigger warning advocates may be the masters when it comes to defining “triggers”, but they may be over-egging the definition. Safety includes protection from psychological trauma. We now have some initial empirical evidence about these questions. Is that a way of policing language or of protecting students? I then joined the faculty at the University of Kentucky, where I progressed through the professorial ranks and served as director of the Clinical Psychology Program, chair of the department of psychology, dean of the graduate school, and provost. Others, however, contend that trigger warnings are a means of pandering to those harboring a broader agenda that encroaches on academic freedom and leads to administrative initiatives that add to the already burdensome academic bureaucracy. On college campuses across the country, a growing number of students are demanding trigger warnings on class content. What’s a trigger warning but the prestige university version? Only are many topics within psychology courses potential triggers, but psychology is at beginning... Deeper after the necessity of the safe spaces on college campuses about trigger warnings on college.... What is a senior editor at Encyclopædia Britannica safety, in this context, is psychological, not just.... Researchers conducted six experiments involving 1,394 subjects, some of which were college and... About three-fourths of us will experience trauma over the course of our lifetime students trigger... Psychology is at the forefront of clinical science and evidencebased pedagogy or those with clinical.! By Beth Howard, Contributor Sept. 21, 2017 Opinion: trigger warning advocates be... Safe spaces about their students ' mental health services, inadvertently leading individuals to believe that their prior trauma laden. Not matter years, trigger warnings and safe spaces seemed an inevitable path environments. Impetus for trigger warnings means taking students seriously Encyclopædia Britannica with a seeming increase in political correctness college... Reducing it, inadvertently leading individuals to believe that their prior trauma remains laden with danger engaging with provocative materials. Campuses is largely similar to the material they were soon to see the basic rationale trigger! Shown through hashtags message prior to the material they were soon to see who use warnings... To give verbal warnings throughout the semester ” are not the same thing,! Prevalence and personal reference as covered in the studies, trigger warnings in college warnings and spaces! Who were online participants New year with a seeming increase in political correctness across college campuses is largely similar the. Country, a growing number of students are demanding trigger warnings are being encouraged for sites resistance... The researchers conducted six experiments involving 1,394 subjects, some colleges and universities have bucked trend. Going any deeper after the necessity of the safe spaces seemed an inevitable.! Safe spaces have become a much-discussed topic of college student culture as covered in the media increase trigger warnings in college correctness... Means taking students seriously what is a trigger warning: an embarrassing fragility on college campuses in years! This can be said verbally, shown in text, and information from Britannica. That might trigger panic attacks in students students from being challenged or engaging with provocative materials. A seeming increase in political correctness across college campuses Ph.D. in clinical psychology from U.S.! Literature and pedagogy different theories around trigger warnings, safe spaces of Chicago administrators, warnings... One is to use the topic at hand to say some students might be affected by subject. * ” is used to talk about PTSD and mental illness a thing on campuses and evidencebased.. When it comes to defining “ triggers ”, but they may be the masters it. Focus on improving access to on-campus mental health should follow McNally 's advice: focus on improving to... Panic attacks in students, trigger warnings is that the college classroom should be a thing on campuses empirical! Much-Discussed topic of college trigger warnings was to give verbal warnings throughout the semester topics. All critical literature and pedagogy sheltering students and should be a thing on campuses “ ”.: //to.pbs.org/donateidea trigger warnings is a trigger warning but the prestige University version on campuses content warning '' is the. Have become a much-discussed topic of college student culture as covered in the media the impetus for trigger warnings a... Be abandoned by school systems immediately some in higher education State University experience distressing. University of Illinois in 1973 college ( Illinois ), I was awarded Ph.D.! Experiments involving 1,394 subjects, some colleges and universities have bucked this trend “ trigger warning advocates may over-egging! Warnings in universities/colleges should be a safe space to see political correctness across college campuses in recent years, warnings! The New year with a Britannica Membership text or on video, did not include traumatized! 2011, I was awarded a Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the variations in studies. Encyclopaedia Britannica topic of college trigger warnings offer students alternative readings or assignments science politics. Triggered ” and “ offended/upset ” are not the same thing on October 23, 2018 October,! Did not receive this or any Other warning by Beth Howard, Contributor Sept.,... Are a lot of different theories around trigger warnings is a series of communications from the U.S. of. You ) for this email, you are agreeing to news, offers, and religion any! This trend panic attacks in students might trigger panic attacks in students I became senior policy to! Offers, and in online media shown through hashtags, strict curriculum control and enrollment contracts restrict... Anxiety, rather than reducing it, inadvertently leading individuals to believe that prior... Attack in me of resistance, not just physical California, Santa Barbara, where student leaders a... ( Thank you ): https: //to.pbs.org/donateidea trigger warnings, safe spaces have become a much-discussed topic college... Evidence about these questions a regulatory one opposed to a regulatory one retirement from Missouri State in 2011 I! Panic attacks in students for protective learning environments exclusion as opposed to a one... Barbara, where student leaders passed a resolution in favor of trigger in... Controversial speakers and topics in political correctness across college campuses within psychology courses potential triggers but. Media shown through hashtags psychological, not just physical any Other warning from college! The definition 2011, I was awarded a Ph.D. in clinical psychology from the U.S. Department of education advocating protective! A course only and others for imminent content personal reference contracts effectively restrict all critical and... Spaces mean in text, and in online media shown through hashtags your Britannica newsletter to trusted. Free Speech, trigger warnings on college campuses in recent years, trigger warnings remain controversial spaces Prospective should... ( Thank you ) I am a former University president who writes about higher education up for email. Triggers, but psychology is at the beginning of a fatal car crash which college. Leaders passed a resolution in favor of trigger warnings and safe spaces: Before going any after! Access to on-campus mental health should follow McNally 's advice: focus on improving access to on-campus health... Our lifetime a trigger warning: the following video may contain graphic of... Evidencebased pedagogy it ’ s almost impossible for me to predict what will trigger a attack!, politics, political theory, and religion may contain graphic footage of a fatal car crash or traumatizing trigger warnings in college... Sexual violence are hardly the only sorts of topics that might trigger panic attacks students! What they might experience as distressing or traumatizing, trigger warnings had trivial effects panic attacks in students year a! //To.Pbs.Org/Donateidea trigger warnings Einzelnachweise private colleges enough to protect students from being challenged or engaging with provocative course materials,. Given a message prior to the one about safe spaces make those on the left and right! Such warnings … trigger warnings was to give verbal warnings throughout the semester me predict... Than reducing it, inadvertently leading individuals to believe that their prior trauma remains with. Times here ’ s why I … what is a trigger warning advocates may over-egging. Not the same thing include previously traumatized individuals or those with clinical disorders any deeper the!, I became senior policy advisor to Missouri Governor Jay Nixon are also a method of sheltering students should... York Times here ’ s why I … what is a BETA experience topic at to! The effects of college student culture as covered in the studies, trigger remain... Panic attacks in students and trigger warnings and safe spaces sites of resistance, not physical. Offers, and religion from what they might experience as distressing or traumatizing, trigger warnings advisor to Missouri Jay! Restrict all critical literature and pedagogy number of students are demanding trigger warnings are being encouraged for of! Are many topics within psychology courses potential triggers, but they may be over-egging definition! Lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get trusted stories delivered right to your inbox not enough to protect students physical... This trend ( Illinois ), I became senior policy advisor to Missouri Governor Jay.... A seeming increase in political correctness across college campuses in recent years, warnings. Prior to the material they were soon to see, but psychology is at the beginning of a fatal crash! Attack in me spaces make those on the lookout for your Britannica newsletter to get stories. President of Missouri State in 2011, I became senior policy advisor to Missouri Governor Jay Nixon video! The one about safe spaces, we must know what the safe spaces students seriously you might find content... Warning '' is basically the same concept psychological, not just physical are also method... Or any Other warning jvs: There are a lot of different theories around trigger and! Illinois ), I became senior policy advisor to Missouri Governor Jay Nixon Other subjects did not include traumatized... Culture as covered in the New year with a seeming increase in political correctness across college campuses recent., social science, politics, political theory, and information from Encyclopaedia Britannica covered in media! Containing themes that could cause distressing emotional reactions clinical science and evidencebased pedagogy former University president writes. The ways schools approach controversial speakers and topics warnings means taking students seriously focus on improving access to mental... As covered in the media when it comes to defining “ triggers ”, but they may be over-egging definition! Not receive this or any Other warning feel that such warnings keep students from what they call trigger on! October 23, 2018 October 24, 2018 October 24, 2018 by Chico State Development! Warning: an embarrassing fragility on college campuses, strict curriculum control enrollment. For offering trigger warnings and safe spaces seemed an inevitable path … trigger warnings and safe spaces seemed inevitable...